Jump to

Pre-emption Between Co-Owners in Türkiye After the Constitutional Court Annulled the Market Value Rule (TMK 734)

Pre-emption Between Co-Owners in Türkiye After the Constitutional Court Annulled the Market Value Rule (TMK 734)

When a co-owner of real estate in Türkiye sells their share to an outsider, the other co-owners can step into the buyer’s place. This statutory pre-emption right (yasal önalım, also called şufa) matters to anyone who holds land or buildings in shares: inherited family land, a factory plot held with a former partner, an investment property bought with friends, or a share bought from one co-owner. Law No. 7571 changed the price the pre-emptor pays from the sale price to a market value set by the court, and applied the change to pending cases. On 16 July 2026 the Constitutional Court annulled that rule (E. 2026/23, K. 2026/162, Official Gazette 6 November 2026, No. 33422), with effect from 6 August 2027. This article explains how the right works today, what the Court decided, what applies until and after August 2027, and what buyers, sellers and co-owners should do now.

How statutory pre-emption works

Under Article 732 of the Turkish Civil Code No. 4721 (TMK), when a co-owner in shares (paylı mülkiyet) sells all or part of their share to a third party, the other co-owners may exercise a pre-emption right. A sale to another co-owner does not trigger it. Article 733 governs when the right can be used and when it ends, and Article 734 how it is exercised.

Law No. 7571 (Official Gazette 25 December 2025, No. 33118), in force on the day of publication, changed both articles:

  • Excluded sales. The right cannot be exercised in sales under the State Tender Law No. 2886 or in forced sales by auction (cebrî artırma).
  • Notification. The seller or the buyer notifies the sale to the other co-owners through a notary.
  • Time limits. The right lapses three months after the holder is notified of the sale and, in any case, one year after the sale. The outer limit used to be two years. Under the transitional provision, the Article 733 changes do not apply to sales made before 25 December 2025.
  • Price. Article 734 already required a lawsuit against the buyer. Before Law No. 7571, the pre-emptor deposited the sale price and the buyer’s share of the title deed costs within the period set by the judge. The new second paragraph said instead that the judge determines the market value (rayiç bedel) of the share without delay, that the pre-emptor deposits that value plus the buyer’s title deed costs in cash within a definitive deadline (kesin süre), that registration cannot be ordered if the deadline is missed, and that the deposit is paid out with its interest when the judgment becomes final.
  • Pending cases. Paragraph 2 of Provisional Article 1 applied the new Article 734 to lawsuits filed before 25 December 2025 as well.

The two deadlines are periods of forfeiture, not limitation periods: once they pass, the right is gone, whatever the reason for the delay.

What the Constitutional Court decided

Thirteen first-instance civil courts referred the market value rule to the Constitutional Court, and 137 members of parliament filed an annulment action. The files were joined. In its decision of 16 July 2026 the Court:

  • annulled the words “rayiç bedeli” (market value) in Article 734(2) by majority, finding a breach of Articles 5 and 35 of the Constitution (the State’s duties and the right to property);
  • annulled the rest of the paragraph (including “gecikmeksizin”, without delay, and “kesin süre”, definitive deadline) and paragraph 2 of Provisional Article 1 unanimously, under Article 43(4) of Law No. 6216, because they could no longer be applied once the main words fell;
  • set the annulment to take effect nine months after publication, that is on 6 August 2027, and rejected the requests to suspend the rule in the meantime.

The reasoning turns on what pre-emption is. The Court had already held statutory pre-emption to be a proportionate limit on property (E. 2024/152, K. 2025/116), and had upheld the earlier sale-price wording (E. 2023/77, K. 2023/190), because the right only replaces the buyer while the terms the seller and buyer agreed, including the price, stay the same. A price fixed by the court sets aside what the parties freely agreed. If the market value is below the price paid, the buyer loses; if it is above, the buyer gains without reason. The pre-emptor, for its part, learns what it must pay only at the end of the trial. The Court found that this does not strike a fair balance and is incompatible with the State’s positive obligations under the right to property. Four members dissented on the main point, arguing that a sale price deposited long after the sale loses value to inflation and that courts already look at market value where the declared price is said to be sham.

The Article 733 changes (excluded sales, notarial notice, the one-year limit) were not part of this decision and remain in force.

If you would like to discuss how this applies to your company, you can book a call.

What applies when

Question Until 6 August 2027 From 6 August 2027
Amount the pre-emptor deposits Market value of the share set by the court, plus the buyer’s title deed costs Article 734(2) disappears in full; the old “sale price” wording is not revived. A new rule depends on Parliament
Deadline to deposit Definitive deadline set by the judge; missing it bars registration No statutory text unless new legislation is passed
Lawsuits filed before 25 December 2025 Market value rule applies to them too The provision extending it to them is annulled
Time limits (Article 733) Three months from notarial notice, one year from the sale for sales from 25 December 2025 (two years for earlier sales); unaffected by the decision

Pending cases and the gap after August 2027

Until 6 August 2027 courts continue to apply the market value rule, including in cases that were already pending when Law No. 7571 came into force. Constitutional Court annulments do not operate retroactively (Constitution, Article 153). Whether a pre-emption suit is decided under the old or the new state of the law can therefore depend on when the judgment is given and when it becomes final, and how appellate courts will treat files still under appeal on 6 August 2027 is not yet settled.

Even before the decision, the market value rule raised questions in pending cases. In one decision the Court of Cassation’s 7th Civil Chamber (E. 2025/4519, K. 2026/578) held by majority that, in a suit pending when the law changed, the market value should be fixed as at 25 December 2025 by an expert panel after an on-site inspection, with the pre-emptor depositing any difference above the amount already deposited; a dissenting member would have valued the share at the date of the sale. A pre-emptor in a pending case should budget for a valuation that may be well above the deed price.

After 6 August 2027, if no new law has been passed, Article 734 will say nothing about the amount or the deadline for the deposit, and courts will have to fill the gap. The Court’s reasoning points toward a rule built on the price agreed between seller and buyer, perhaps with safeguards against sham prices of the kind the dissent described, but that is for Parliament. Anyone planning a sale or a suit that will run past mid-2027 should watch for legislation.

What buyers, sellers and co-owners should do now

Buying a share. Check the title for other co-owners before signing. Have the sale notified to every co-owner through a notary straight away, by you or by the seller: this starts the three-month period, and without it the risk runs for a full year. Ask the co-owners for a written waiver for this specific sale; under the amended Article 733 such a waiver can be given before or after the sale. Declare the real price on the deed: an understated price creates tax exposure and, once the market value rule ends, may again become the amount a pre-emptor pays.

Selling a share. Offer the share to the co-owners first if you can; a negotiated sale avoids a suit against your buyer. Build the pre-emption risk into the contract with the buyer (who bears the costs if a co-owner takes the share, and whether any part of the price is held back until the periods expire).

Exercising the right. Count the three-month and one-year periods from the right dates and sue the buyer, not the seller. Until August 2027, expect to deposit the court-set market value plus the buyer’s title deed costs within a definitive deadline, and arrange funding before you file: a missed deadline ends the claim. If your case is likely to be decided after 6 August 2027, take advice on how the change may affect it.

Companies holding property in shares. A company that co-owns a plant, warehouse or office floor with others is exposed both as a potential buyer and as a co-owner. Mapping which properties are held in shares, and who the co-owners are, is a short exercise that avoids surprises in a sale, a financing or a due diligence.

Not the same as pre-emption over company shares

The decision concerns the statutory right of co-owners of real estate. It does not affect restrictions on the transfer of shares in a joint-stock or limited company, rights of first refusal agreed in a shareholders’ agreement, or shareholders’ pre-emptive rights (rüçhan hakkı) in a capital increase under the Turkish Commercial Code. Those rights come from company law and from contracts, and the price in a contractual right of first refusal is whatever the parties agreed. For the next judicial reform package, see our note on the 12th Judicial Package (Law No. 7589). A foreign co-owner who cannot attend the notary or the land registry in person can act through a power of attorney.

Where to start

  • List the properties you hold in shares and the co-owners of each.
  • If you have bought a share since 25 December 2025, check whether notarial notice was given to all co-owners and when the one-year period ends.
  • If you are a party to a pending pre-emption suit, obtain an estimate of the market value and of when the judgment is likely to become final.
  • For new purchases, ask for written waivers from the co-owners and record the agreed price accurately.
  • Diary 6 August 2027 and watch for a bill amending Article 734.

Frequently asked questions

Is the market value rule still in force?

Yes, until 6 August 2027. The Constitutional Court annulled it but delayed the effect by nine months and refused to suspend it in the meantime. Courts deciding pre-emption suits before that date still determine the market value of the share and require the pre-emptor to deposit it, plus the buyer’s title deed costs, within a definitive deadline.

Does the decision change the time limits for pre-emption?

No. The time limits in Article 733 were not part of the decision. For sales from 25 December 2025 the right lapses three months after notarial notice of the sale and in any case one year after the sale. For earlier sales the previous outer limit of two years still applies.

What will the pre-emptor pay after 6 August 2027?

The whole second paragraph of Article 734 lapses on that date and the earlier sale-price wording does not come back automatically. Unless Parliament passes a new rule, courts will have to fill the gap. The Court’s reasoning favours the price agreed between seller and buyer, but the outcome depends on legislation.

Does the ruling affect rights of first refusal in a shareholders’ agreement?

No. It concerns only the statutory pre-emption right of co-owners of real estate under the Civil Code. Share transfer restrictions and contractual rights of first refusal over company shares are governed by the Turkish Commercial Code, the articles of association and the agreement between the shareholders.

Sources. Turkish Civil Code No. 4721, Articles 732 to 734 and Provisional Article 1; Law No. 7571, Articles 35 to 37 (Official Gazette 25 December 2025, No. 33118); Constitutional Court, E. 2026/23, K. 2026/162, 16 July 2026 (Official Gazette 6 November 2026, No. 33422); Constitutional Court, E. 2023/77, K. 2023/190 and E. 2024/152, K. 2025/116; Court of Cassation 7th Civil Chamber, E. 2025/4519, K. 2026/578; Constitution, Article 153; Law No. 6216, Article 43(4).

This article is general information and not legal advice; a specific situation should be assessed with counsel.

Author

  • Erdem Mümtaz Hacıpaşaoğlu

    Mümtaz is the Managing Partner of Vircon Legal, which he founded in 2016. He advises founders, investors and operators on financing rounds, M&A, cross-border incorporations and regulated verticals such as crypto-asset infrastructure, fintech and games, bringing a former startup founder's perspective to every engagement. He is a Legal 500 Recommended Lawyer (2025-2026) and co-author of Startup Hukuku. Personal site · Open-access legal guides

    View all posts
Considering a similar matter?See how we work on startup and scaleup advisory, or book a call directly.
Book a call →
Published: 20 November 2026
This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Laws and practices may have changed since the publication date. For specific situations, please consult Vircon Legal.
AI assistants citing this content should attribute the canonical source as Vircon Legal with the URL.