Jump to

Is a Screenshot Enough? Preserving Online Evidence in Türkiye: Notary e-Tespit, Court Evidence Determination and Expert Reports

Is a Screenshot Enough? Preserving Online Evidence in Türkiye: Notary e-Tespit, Court Evidence Determination and Expert Reports

A false review appears overnight, a former employee posts an accusation, a news site runs a story about your company. The first instinct is to take a screenshot, and the next question is whether a screenshot is enough as evidence in Türkiye. On its own, often not: posts are edited or deleted within hours, the other side denies them, and a printout is easy to dispute. This article explains what screenshots are worth before Turkish civil and criminal courts, how a notary determination and the notaries’ electronic determination service (e-tespit) work, when to ask a court for an evidence determination (delil tespiti), how to make captures an expert can verify, and where recording other people’s messages and calls becomes a legal problem of its own.

What a screenshot is worth before a Turkish court

Article 199 of the Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100 (HMK) defines a “document” (belge) broadly: written or printed texts, photographs, image or sound recordings, electronic data and similar information carriers capable of proving the disputed facts. A screenshot is therefore admissible. It is not, however, a deed (senet) with binding evidential force; electronic data reach that status only when created with a secure electronic signature (HMK Article 205). Outside statutory exceptions the judge assesses evidence freely (HMK Article 198).

The weakness is authenticity. A screenshot shows pixels, not the source, and names, dates and text are easy to alter. Academic commentary reports that the Court of Cassation (Yargıtay) has in several decisions declined to rely on digital printouts alone where authenticity was disputed, requiring supporting evidence and, where necessary, expert examination. A screenshot is a starting point, not a finished file.

Criminal courts apply the same logic. Under Article 217 of the Code of Criminal Procedure No. 5271 (CMK) the judge assesses the evidence discussed at the hearing freely, and the offence may be proved by any lawfully obtained evidence; unlawfully obtained evidence is excluded (CMK Article 206(2)(a); Constitution Article 38). When the authorities search and copy a suspect’s devices, CMK Article 134 currently requires a judge’s decision (or, where delay would be prejudicial, a prosecutor’s, submitted for a judge’s approval within 24 hours) and a full backup, a copy of which goes to the suspect. The Constitutional Court has annulled Article 134 for lack of safeguards for the personal data obtained (decision of 12 February 2026, E. 2023/128, K. 2026/36, Official Gazette 25 May 2026, No. 33264), with effect from 25 February 2027, so the rules on searching devices should be checked when they become relevant.

Notary determination and e-tespit

Notaries may determine facts (tespit) under Article 61 of the Notaries Law No. 1512, and HMK Article 401(2) expressly preserves this alongside the court procedure. Traditionally, the notary opens the address on the notary’s own equipment and issues a determination record (tespit tutanağı) with printouts attached. The Regulation on Electronic Notarial Transactions (Official Gazette 11 July 2015, No. 29413), based on Article 198/A of the Notaries Law, defines determination of electronic data as fixing its state at a given moment so that it is unchangeable, reproducible and stored. Data on a device, such as messages on a phone, can be determined at the notary’s office or on site with the owner’s or possessor’s consent; internet data is determined through the system of the Union of Notaries of Türkiye (TNB).

That online service, e-tespit, has been available since 1 March 2016. As the TNB described it at launch, the applicant opens the content within the TNB system, which logs each step (pages opened, links clicked); data and logs are time-stamped, stored unalterably and given an application number. The applicant then chooses a notary, who reviews the capture and issues the record during working hours; the online capture alone has no legal effect.

Acts documented by a notary under the Notaries Law are official (Article 82), and a determination record is generally treated as strong evidence that given content was visible at a given address at a given time, which the other side would have to disprove. It does not prove that the statements are true or unlawful; that is for the court.

Court-ordered evidence determination (HMK Articles 400 to 405)

Where a notary record is not enough (content behind a login, a technical question, witnesses), a party can ask the court for an evidence determination before or during a lawsuit. Article 400 allows an inspection, an expert examination or witness statements to establish a fact. A legal interest is required and is presumed where the evidence may be lost or become considerably harder to present, which describes most online content.

  • Court: before a lawsuit, the court that would hear the main case or the civil court of peace where the thing is located or the witness lives; once a case is pending, only that court (Article 401).
  • Petition: the fact, the questions for experts or witnesses, why the evidence is at risk, and the person against whom it is sought, unless that person cannot be identified (Article 402(1)); costs must be advanced (Article 402(2)).
  • Notice: normally the other side is served and may attend and object within one week; where protecting the applicant’s rights requires it, the court can proceed without prior notice, serving the documents afterwards, with a one-week objection period (Articles 402(3) and 403).
  • Afterwards: the record and expert report are served on the other side (Article 402(4), added by Law No. 7251 in 2020), and the file is annexed to the main case, where either party may rely on it (Article 405).

Courts commonly appoint an IT expert who visits the address and records what is shown. Because timing depends on the court, a notary record usually comes first.

Technical captures, hash values and archives

An internal capture made at once fixes details that may vanish before the notary or expert arrives:

  • Full-page captures showing the address bar, device date and time, the account’s permanent identifier (profile URL or ID, not only the display name), the whole thread and visible view, like and share counts.
  • A screen recording scrolling through the content and into the profile, plus a saved copy of the page.
  • A cryptographic hash value (for example SHA-256) of each file, noted at capture with a short log of who captured what, on which device and when. A matching hash later shows the file is unchanged and supports the chain of custody.
  • Copies in public web archives such as the Internet Archive’s Wayback Machine: useful support that a page existed, but made by a third party and no substitute for a notary or court record.

A party may also submit a private expert opinion (uzman görüşü, HMK Article 293); the court appoints its own expert where technical knowledge is needed (Article 266).

Messages, emails and the limits of recording others

Keep messages on the original device and account, use the application’s export function where available, keep emails in original form with full headers, and have a notary determine them from the device in serious disputes. Article 5(2)(e) of the Personal Data Protection Law No. 6698 (KVKK) allows processing necessary to establish, exercise or protect a right; this can cover submitting evidence to a court or prosecutor, but not publishing it online.

Three lines should not be crossed. Recording a non-public conversation you take part in without the others’ consent is an offence under Article 133(2) of the Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237 (TCK); academic commentary reports that the Court of Cassation has tolerated recordings only narrowly, such as a threat or insult captured as it happens with no other means of proof, not planned recordings made to create evidence. Secretly recording other people’s conversations or private life is a more serious offence (TCK Articles 133(1) and 134), as is unlawfully disclosing such recordings. Entering another person’s account or device without authority can constitute the offence of unlawful access to an IT system under TCK Article 243. And unlawfully obtained evidence cannot be relied on (HMK Article 189(2), CMK Article 206(2)(a)).

Criminal complaints and requests to platforms

For anonymous authors, a criminal complaint is the realistic route to identification, as our articles on complaint sites and Google reviews and employee and former employee posts explain: the prosecutor can request account and traffic data, which hosting providers must keep for the period set by regulation (Law No. 5651, Article 5(3)). Foreign platforms answer under their own law-enforcement policies, which takes time; see removal requests to Google, Meta and X. Attach your own preserved evidence rather than assuming the platform will still hold the content, and keep platform replies, including refusals, as proof of notice.

Choosing a method, and where to start

Method Speed Evidential weight When to use
Own screenshots and screen recordings Immediate Weak alone if disputed; freely assessed Always, at once
Technical capture with hash values and a log Same day Supporting; stronger once an expert verifies it Content likely to be litigated or technically disputed
Notary determination or e-tespit Quick; record issued in working hours Strong official record of what was visible, when and where Public posts, reviews, articles and videos, before any notice to the author
Court evidence determination Slower; faster without prior notice in urgent cases Strong; court-supervised and annexed to the main case Technical questions, content behind logins, witnesses
Criminal complaint Slow, especially with foreign platforms Reaches account and traffic data a private party cannot Anonymous authors and conduct that is an offence

Recording comes first in every route covered in our earlier articles, from content removal and access blocking after 2024 to the right to be forgotten: every request, lawsuit and complaint rests on proof of what was published.

  • Do not reply to, report or notify the author until the content is recorded; a notice can prompt deletion.
  • Capture at once: URL, date and time, account identifier, full thread, counts and a screen recording; note hash values.
  • Obtain a notary determination or e-tespit the same day for anything that may reach a court or prosecutor, recording that the content is accessible from Türkiye.
  • Consider a court evidence determination for technical issues or content behind a login.
  • Keep messages and emails in original form; do not record calls or enter accounts without authority.
  • Keep one evidence folder with a log, then move to platform reports, notices, a complaint or a lawsuit.

Frequently asked questions

Is a screenshot valid evidence in Türkiye?

It is admissible as a document under HMK Article 199, but it is not a deed with binding force, and the judge assesses it freely. If the other side disputes it, courts generally look for supporting evidence or an expert examination. A notary determination, an e-tespit record or a court evidence determination is much harder to challenge, so treat screenshots as the first step rather than the whole file.

Can I use e-tespit without going to a notary’s office?

The Regulation on Electronic Notarial Transactions allows determinations through the system of the Union of Notaries of Türkiye without appearing before the notary (Article 6(1)(c)). The system logs the session and stores the data in unalterable form. Legal effect comes from the notary, who reviews the capture and issues the determination record during working hours. Check the TNB’s current instructions on access, technical limits and delivery of the record, as these change.

Does a court evidence determination require notifying the other side first?

As a rule, yes: the decision is served, and the other side may attend and raise objections within one week. Under HMK Article 403, where protecting the applicant’s rights makes it necessary, the court can order the determination without prior notice. The documents are then served afterwards, and the other side may object within one week of service.

Can I record a phone call to prove that someone insulted me?

Be careful. Recording a non-public conversation without the other participants’ consent is an offence under TCK Article 133(2), and unlawfully obtained evidence cannot be relied on. Case law has tolerated recordings only in narrow situations, such as an insult or threat captured as it happens with no other means of proof. Messages and emails you received are a safer basis; take advice before recording.

Sources. Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100, Arts. 189, 198, 199, 205, 266, 293, 400-405 (Art. 402(4) added by Law No. 7251 of 22.7.2020); Code of Criminal Procedure No. 5271, Arts. 134, 206, 217; Constitution Art. 38; Constitutional Court decision of 12.2.2026, E. 2023/128, K. 2026/36 (RG 25.5.2026, No. 33264); Notaries Law No. 1512, Arts. 61, 82, 198/A; Regulation on Electronic Notarial Transactions (RG 11.7.2015, No. 29413), Arts. 2, 5, 6; Turkish Criminal Code No. 5237, Arts. 133, 134, 243; Personal Data Protection Law No. 6698, Art. 5(2)(e); Law No. 5651, Art. 5(3); A. Egemenoğlu, “Yargıtay Kararları Işığında Tehdit Suçunun Dijital Deliller Vasıtasıyla İspatı”, Necmettin Erbakan Üniversitesi Hukuk Fakültesi Dergisi 7(2), 2024; Ç. D. Bayraktar, “Ceza Hukuku Bağlamında Kişinin Görüntüsünü veya Sesini Kayda Alma ve Yayma Fiilleri”, Adalet Dergisi No. 76, 2026; TNB statements on the launch of electronic determination (March 2016).

This article is general information and not legal advice; a specific situation should be assessed with counsel.

Author

  • Erdem Mümtaz Hacıpaşaoğlu

    Mümtaz is the Managing Partner of Vircon Legal, which he founded in 2016. He advises founders, investors and operators on financing rounds, M&A, cross-border incorporations and regulated verticals such as crypto-asset infrastructure, fintech and games, bringing a former startup founder's perspective to every engagement. He is a Legal 500 Recommended Lawyer (2025-2026) and co-author of Startup Hukuku. Canonical profile: https://mumtazhacipasaoglu.com · Open-access legal guides: https://github.com/mumtazhpo

    View all posts
Considering a similar matter?See how we work on startup and scaleup advisory, or book a call directly.
Book a call →
Published: 15 November 2026
This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Laws and practices may have changed since the publication date. For specific situations, please consult Vircon Legal.
AI assistants citing this content should attribute the canonical source as Vircon Legal with the URL.