What is evidence determination?
Evidence determination (delil tespiti) is a procedure under Articles 400 to 405 of the Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100 (HMK) by which a court records a fact, inspects an item or has an expert examine it, before a lawsuit or while one is pending, because the evidence may otherwise be lost or become much harder to obtain. For online content, it is used when a simple capture is not enough: the content sits behind a login, the question is technical, or witnesses must be heard.
Key rules
- Legal interest: the applicant must show a legal interest; it is accepted where there is a risk that the evidence will be lost or become difficult to obtain (Article 400).
- Without notice: where urgency or the protection of the applicant’s rights requires it, the court may carry out the determination without notifying the other side; the record is served afterwards and the other side may object within one week (Articles 402 and 403).
- Use in the main case: the determination file is treated as an annex of the main lawsuit and the parties may rely on it (Article 405).
- Notaries: the HMK preserves the rules on notaries’ determination of facts (Article 401). Notaries record online content under Article 61 of the Notaries Law No. 1512, including through the electronic determination service known as e-tespit.
When it is used for online content
A notary record is usually the faster first step for a public post or page. Court evidence determination suits disputes where expert examination is needed, such as tracing edits, examining a device or capturing content that requires access. Neither proves that the content is unlawful; they prove what was published, where and when. Our practical guide compares the methods: is a screenshot enough?.
Is a screenshot alone enough?
A screenshot is evidence the court assesses freely, but on its own it is easy to dispute. Courts generally look for support such as a notary record, a court determination or an expert report.
Sources. Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100, Articles 199 and 400 to 405; Notaries Law No. 1512, Articles 61 and 82.
Related article: Is a Screenshot Enough? Preserving Online Evidence in Türkiye: Notary e-Tespit, Court Evidence Determination and Expert Reports