Artificial intelligence is now a normal part of legal work, and it should be: it drafts, summarises and compares documents in minutes. What it cannot do is take responsibility for what it writes. On 13 November 2026 the President of the European Court of Human Rights barred a Romanian lawyer from representing applicants before the Court for two years, because her written observations, drafted with AI tools, cited cases that do not exist, paragraphs that do not exist in real judgments, and real judgments that said the opposite of what she claimed. The Court announced the decision in press release ECHR 290 (2026) on 18 November 2026. This article explains what the Court found, how the same failure has played out in the United States, England and Türkiye, why these errors are so easy to make, and how companies and their lawyers can use AI without signing their name under something nobody has checked.
What the Court decided
The lawyer was one of two representatives in a pending application. The Chamber dealing with the case found that her observations contained numerous errors about the Court’s case-law, of three kinds:
- Non-existent cases. Judgments that were never delivered, cited as if they were.
- Fictitious paragraphs in genuine judgments. A real case name, with a paragraph number that does not contain the proposition, or does not exist.
- Real but wrong authority. Existing case-law that was irrelevant to the point made, or that plainly contradicted it.
The lawyer accepted that she had used AI tools and called the problems “inaccuracies” and “citation errors”. The Chamber did not accept that description. It found a pattern of numerous, repeated, substantive errors rather than isolated slips, and held that her admission that she had not checked all the case-law sufficiently was an understatement: for some references no check had been made at all, and many errors would have been caught by a cursory search of HUDOC, the Court’s case-law database.
The Chamber relied on the Romanian Legal Profession Act (Law No. 51/1995), the rules of the profession and the Court’s own case-law: a lawyer must act as a reasonably competent professional and, before the Court, show a high level of professional prudence. That meant checking every reference and argument produced by AI against authoritative sources before filing. The errors had also harmed the administration of justice, because the Court had to spend considerable time verifying the observations, open proceedings under Rule 44D of the Rules of Court and correspond with the Romanian Government and bar associations. The Chamber found that the “exceptional circumstances” threshold of Rule 44D was met and proposed a two-year exclusion, which the President approved. The exclusion applies only to her, not to the second representative, and her right of representation can be restored under Rule 44D § 3.
Not an isolated case
The problem has been building for three years, in very different courts.
| Where and when | What happened |
|---|---|
| United States, Mata v. Avianca, Southern District of New York, 22 June 2023 | A brief cited decisions generated by a chatbot that did not exist. The court found bad faith under Rule 11 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and fined the lawyers USD 5,000. |
| England, Ayinde and Al-Haroun, Divisional Court, 6 June 2025, [2025] EWHC 1383 (Admin) | Five fictitious cases in one set of judicial review grounds; 18 non-existent cases among 45 citations in another, with many of the rest misquoted. The lawyers were referred to their regulators. The court said the duty to check AI output against authoritative sources also applies to research done by colleagues or supplied by the client, and that managing partners and heads of chambers must take practical measures, since guidance alone is not enough. |
| Türkiye, a civil court of first instance in Kızılcahamam (Ankara), June 2026 | According to press reports, a defence petition cited Court of Cassation decisions whose file and decision numbers could not be found on UYAP as cited. The court referred the lawyer to the Ankara Bar and the public prosecutor on the day of the hearing. The lawyer said the decisions’ content was genuine and only the numbers, added with AI, were wrong. No outcome had been reported at the time of writing. |
| European Court of Human Rights, 13 November 2026 | Two-year exclusion of a representative under Rule 44D, as described above. |
The sanctions differ, but the reasoning is the same everywhere: the tool is not the problem, the missing check is. None of these courts said lawyers may not use AI.
If you would like to discuss how this applies to your company, you can book a call.
Why these errors are easy to make
A large language model writes the most plausible next words. A case citation has a very predictable shape, so the model can produce one that looks right without any source behind it. In Türkiye the shape is especially easy to imitate: a chamber, an esas number, a karar number and a date. A made-up “Yargıtay 11. HD, E. 2019/…, K. 2020/…” reads exactly like a real one.
The three error types in the Strasbourg case are also not equally easy to catch. A non-existent case disappears with one database search. A wrong paragraph number needs the judgment to be opened. A real case that does not support the point, or contradicts it, is caught only by reading the passage, and that is the check most often skipped because the citation “exists”. Tools connected to a legal database reduce the first risk; they do not remove the third.
A Turkish court applies the law of its own motion (Article 33 of the Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100), so a wrong citation rarely decides a case by itself. What it does decide is how much the court trusts everything else in the petition, and, as the Kızılcahamam file shows, it can open disciplinary and criminal inquiries against the person who signed. Under Article 34 of the Attorneys’ Act No. 1136, a lawyer must perform the work with care and accuracy; there is no exception for text a machine wrote.
Not only a lawyers’ problem
The same risk sits inside companies. In-house teams use AI to draft replies to the Personal Data Protection Authority, answers to data subject requests, warning letters, employment notices, responses to Capital Markets Board or BDDK requests and contract summaries for the board. The person who signs is responsible for what the document says, whoever or whatever drafted it. Our notes on who pays when AI output is wrong and on an internal AI use policy cover the corporate side.
A second risk is what goes into the tool. The Personal Data Protection Authority published guidance on generative AI and personal data in November 2025, and its 2026 application guide on personal data in lawyers’ professional activities addresses AI tools directly: uploading case documents to a generative AI service may involve a transfer of personal data abroad under Article 9 of the KVKK, depending on where the provider, its servers and sub-processors sit. The guide recommends checking the provider’s terms and sub-processors, masking data where possible, sharing only what is needed and keeping special-category data out of these systems. For lawyers, professional secrecy under Article 36 of the Attorneys’ Act applies on top of this; for companies, so do trade secrets and confidentiality clauses. More on the data side is in our piece on generative AI at work and the KVKK.
How to use AI in legal work safely
| Use it for | Use it, then verify | Do not |
|---|---|---|
| Structuring a first draft, summarising a document you have, comparing two versions, building a checklist, a first translation | Case citations and quotations, article numbers, deadlines, monetary thresholds, whether a rule is still in force | Ask it to find “a Court of Cassation decision that says X” and file what comes back; upload special-category data or client secrets to a tool nobody has reviewed |
For Turkish sources the authoritative places to check are the official databases: the Court of Cassation’s decision search and UYAP’s precedent search for judicial decisions, the Constitutional Court’s decisions database, the Official Gazette and mevzuat.gov.tr for legislation, and HUDOC for the European Court of Human Rights. A citation that cannot be found there should not be filed, however convincing it looks.
Where to start
- Write down which AI tools may be used for legal work, by whom, and with which data. A short policy that people follow is better than a long one they do not.
- Make citation checking a separate step with a named person: open every cited decision and statute in an official source and read the passage relied on.
- Check three things for each citation: the decision exists, the number and date match, and the passage supports the point made.
- Treat research from colleagues, consultants or the business team the same way; the English court said so expressly.
- Before uploading documents, check where the provider processes data, remove names and identifiers where you can, and keep special-category data out.
- Keep a record of what was generated and what was checked. If something goes wrong, the record shows the care taken.
Frequently asked questions
Is it forbidden to use AI in legal work in Türkiye?
No. There is no general prohibition on lawyers or in-house teams using AI tools. The ordinary rules apply: the lawyer’s duty of care and accuracy under Article 34 of the Attorneys’ Act, professional secrecy, and the KVKK when personal data is involved. Responsibility for the filed text stays with the person who signs it.
What did the European Court of Human Rights decide?
On 13 November 2026 the President of the Court, on a Chamber’s reasoned proposal under Rule 44D of the Rules of Court, excluded a Romanian lawyer from representing or assisting applicants for two years. Her AI-drafted observations cited non-existent cases, fictitious paragraphs in real judgments and case-law that contradicted her submissions. The decision was announced on 18 November 2026.
Can a wrong AI citation lead to an investigation in Türkiye?
It has. In June 2026 a civil court in Kızılcahamam referred a lawyer to the bar and the public prosecutor after Court of Cassation citations in his petition could not be found on UYAP as cited. The outcome had not been reported at the time of writing.
How do I check a Court of Cassation citation?
Search the chamber, esas and karar numbers in the Court of Cassation’s decision search or UYAP’s precedent search, open the full text, confirm the date, and read the passage you rely on. If the decision cannot be found, do not cite it.
Sources. European Court of Human Rights, press release ECHR 290 (2026), 18 November 2026, and Rules of Court, Rule 44D; Mata v. Avianca, Inc., No. 22-cv-1461 (S.D.N.Y. 22 June 2023); R (Ayinde) v London Borough of Haringey; Al-Haroun v Qatar National Bank [2025] EWHC 1383 (Admin); press reports of 17 and 18 June 2026 on the Kızılcahamam civil court file; Attorneys’ Act No. 1136, Articles 34 and 36; Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100, Article 33; Personal Data Protection Law No. 6698, Article 9; Personal Data Protection Authority, Guide on Generative Artificial Intelligence and the Protection of Personal Data (15 Questions), November 2025, and Application Guide on the Protection of Personal Data in Lawyers’ Professional Activities, 2026.
This article is general information and not legal advice; a specific situation should be assessed with counsel.
Author
-
View all postsMümtaz is the Managing Partner of Vircon Legal, which he founded in 2016. He advises founders, investors and operators on financing rounds, M&A, cross-border incorporations and regulated verticals such as crypto-asset infrastructure, fintech and games, bringing a former startup founder's perspective to every engagement. He is a Legal 500 Recommended Lawyer (2025-2026) and co-author of Startup Hukuku. Personal site · Open-access legal guides
More from Vircon Insights
Türkiye's Draft Trade Secrets Law: What the Ministry of Trade's Text Says and What Startups Should Do Now
November 19, 2026Payment Institution or E-Money Institution? The Law 6493 Licence Decision for a Fintech in Türkiye (Arts. 12, 14, 18)
November 19, 2026Investor Residence Permit in Türkiye: USD 150,000 for Three Years, USD 200,000 for Five (Presidential Decision No. 11994)
November 18, 2026Listing a Token on a Turkish Crypto Platform: III-35/B.2 Listing Principles and Procedure (Law 6362 Art. 35/C(2))
November 18, 2026Crypto-Asset Custody in Türkiye: Client Asset Segregation (Law 6362 Art. 35/C), Custodians and Banks (III-35/B.2)
November 17, 2026Right of Reply (Tekzip) Against News Sites in Türkiye: Deadlines, Drafting and the Court Route under Press Law Article 14
November 16, 2026Related Practice Areas
Privacy & Cybersecurity
KVKK and GDPR compliance, breach response, cybersecurity governance.
View service →Corporate Law
Share transfers, capital increases, board structuring, governance.
View service →US Company Formations & Flip-Ups
Delaware C-Corp, flip-up structures, SAFE/convertible notes, 83(b).
View service →